Steam Cleaner Vs Carpet Cleaner: What’s the Best Option in 2024

Published on:
This post may contain affiliate links, and we will be compensated if you buy after clicking on our links
Read our review guidelines.

If you’ve ever pondered the distinction between a steam cleaner and a carpet cleaner, there’s more to it than meets the eye. The choice between these two cleaning tools can significantly impact the outcome of your cleaning efforts.

From the deep sanitizing power of steam cleaners to the stain-busting capabilities of carpet cleaners, each has its unique advantages. But which one is the right fit for your specific cleaning needs? Understanding the nuances between these cleaning methods is crucial for making an informed decision.

Let’s begin by exploring the key differences and benefits of steam cleaner vs carpet cleaners to help you determine the most suitable option for your cleaning requirements.

Effectiveness Comparison

When comparing the effectiveness of steam cleaners and carpet cleaners, steam cleaners excel in killing bacteria and allergens more efficiently. Steam cleaners utilize high temperatures to sanitize carpets without the need for harsh chemicals, making them a more natural and eco-friendly option. The high temperature of steam not only eliminates germs but also penetrates deep into carpet fibers, effectively removing tough stains and odors. In contrast, carpet cleaners rely on hot water and cleaning solutions to deep clean carpets, utilizing powerful brushes to agitate and lift dirt from the fibers.

While carpet cleaners are effective at lifting dirt, steam cleaners offer a more thorough and hygienic cleaning process, making them ideal for households with allergies or pets. Additionally, steam cleaners can be used on a variety of surfaces beyond carpets, such as tiles and upholstery. The efficient cleaning power of steam cleaners combined with their shorter drying time compared to carpet cleaners makes them a practical choice for maintaining a clean and healthy home environment.

Our Top Picks

Best Overall Steam Cleaner

Hoover PowerScrub Deluxe Carpet Cleaner Machine, Upright Shampooer, FH50150NC, Red

Hoover Power-Scrub Cleaner

SpinScrub Brushes for powerful dirt and stain removal.

HeatForce technology for faster drying.

Includes tools to target tough stains on upholstery and stairs.

Best Overall Carpet Cleaner

BISSELL ProHeat 2X Revolution Pet Pro Plus, 3588F, Upright Deep Cleaner

Bissell ProHeat 2X Carpet Cleaner

Brush roll cover is removable for easy cleaning.

Express Clean Mode leaves carpets dry in about 30 minutes.

Has a built-in stain pre-treater spray nozzle.

Hoover Power-Scrub Cleaner

Reasons to Buy

Reason #1 – SpinScrub Brushes for powerful dirt and stain removal.

Reason #2 – HeatForce technology for faster drying.

Reason #3 – Includes tools to target tough stains on upholstery and stairs.

Reasons to Avoid

Reason #1 – Excessive heat and moisture may not be suitable for all carpet types.

If you desire a powerful and efficient carpet cleaner that can tackle deep-embedded dirt and stains while being gentle on your carpets, the Hoover Power-Scrub Cleaner stands out as the best overall choice. With SpinScrub Brushes that powerfully remove dirt and stains, HeatForce for faster drying, and tools to target tough stains on upholstery and stairs, this cleaner offers a comprehensive solution.

The dual tank technology makes it easy to fill, empty, and rinse, while the dual V nozzle ensures equal suction for quick and even cleaning. Included tools like an 8 ft hose, stair tool, upholstery tool, and crevice tool, along with a sample bottle of carpet cleaning solution, provide everything you need for a thorough clean.

Best For: Those seeking a powerful and efficient carpet cleaner that can effectively remove deep-embedded dirt and stains while being gentle on carpets.

BrandHoover
ColorRed
Item Weight1.06 Pounds
Product Dimensions21.9″D x 14.6″W x 23″H
Capacity3.8 Liters
Power SourceCorded Electric

Bissell ProHeat 2X Revolution Pet Pro Carpet Cleaner

Reasons to Buy

Reason #1 – Brush roll cover is removable for easy cleaning.

Reason #2 – Express Clean Mode leaves carpets dry in about 30 minutes.

Reason #3 – Has a built-in stain pre-treater spray nozzle.

Reasons to Avoid

Reason #1 – Hose and tools must be stored separately.

Ideal for pet owners looking for a powerful and efficient deep cleaning solution, the Bissell ProHeat 2X Revolution Pet Pro Carpet Cleaner stands out as the best overall choice in the comparison between steam cleaners and carpet cleaners. Bissell’s ProHeat 2X Revolution Pet Pro offers a Power Rating of 6.8 Amps and features a corded Power Source with a 35’ Power Cord Length, providing ample reach for cleaning. The machine’s MAX Clean Mode ensures professional-grade cleaning to tackle tough pet stains and odors, outperforming leading rental options.

With a 2-in-1 Pet Upholstery Tool and a bonus Tough Stain Tool, you can effectively remove pet hair, stains, and odors from various surfaces. Additionally, the Express Clean Mode delivers a fast dry time of approximately 30 minutes, making it a convenient choice for busy households.

Best For: Pet owners and Home Owners seeking a powerful and efficient deep cleaning solution for tackling tough pet stains, odors, and dirty carpets.

ManufacturerBISSELL
Package Dimensions23.9 x 18.2 x 14 inches
Item Weight25.4 pounds

Steam Cleaner Overview

Steam cleaners, being more effective in killing bacteria and allergens compared to carpet cleaners, offer a versatile and eco-friendly cleaning solution for various surfaces beyond just carpets. When considering whether to steam clean or use a carpet cleaner for your floors, it’s essential to understand the benefits of steam cleaning:

  • Deep Cleaning: Steam cleaners penetrate carpet fibers to remove embedded grime and dirt more effectively than traditional carpet cleaners.
  • Sanitization: Steam cleaning not only cleans your carpet but also kills germs and bacteria, providing a healthier environment for your family.
  • Versatility: In addition to carpets, steam cleaners can be used on a variety of surfaces such as tiles, hardwood floors, and upholstery, offering a comprehensive cleaning solution for your home.

Carpet Cleaner Overview

For a more budget-friendly and user-friendly approach to deep cleaning carpets, consider utilizing a carpet cleaner that uses a combination of water, cleaning solution, and brushes. Carpet cleaners are ideal for carpet shampooing and deep cleaning your carpets without the use of steam.

When comparing carpet cleaning vs. steam cleaner uses, carpet cleaners are a safer option for maintaining delicate fibers and preserving carpet quality. Unlike steam cleaners, which use high-temperature steam for cleaning, carpet cleaners typically employ hot water extraction methods to clean stains effectively.

When choosing between steam cleaners and carpet cleaners, keep in mind that carpet cleaners are generally more affordable and easier to use. They provide an efficient way to deep clean your carpets without the risk of damage that may come with excessive heat and moisture from steam cleaning.

Opt for a carpet cleaner for a reliable and convenient solution to keeping your carpets fresh and sanitized.

Cleaning Mechanism Differences

istockphoto.com

To understand the dissimilarities in cleaning mechanisms between steam cleaners and carpet cleaners, focus on their distinct approaches to removing dirt and stains from carpets.

  • steam cleaner utilizes high-pressure hot water vapor to clean and sanitize carpets effectively, while a carpet cleaner employs a combination of water, cleaning solution, and brushes for deep cleaning.
  • Steam cleaners excel in killing bacteria and allergens due to their higher temperatures, whereas carpet cleaners rely on powerful brushes to agitate and lift dirt from carpet fibers.
  • Steam cleaners use only water and heat, making them more environmentally friendly, whereas carpet cleaners may require the use of chemical cleaning solutions, potentially harmful to the environment.

The steam cleaner focuses on the power of steam to deep clean and sanitize, while the carpet cleaner relies on a combination of water, cleaning solutions, and brushes to tackle dirt and stains effectively. Understanding these differences can help you choose the most suitable cleaning method for your carpets.

Pros and Cons of Steam Cleaning

Understanding the differences in cleaning mechanisms between steam cleaners and carpet cleaners, you can now examine the pros and cons of utilizing steam cleaning for your carpet maintenance needs.

Steam cleaners, utilizing high temperatures, effectively kill bacteria and allergens, making them a hygienic choice. They also require less drying time than carpet cleaners, allowing for quicker use of your carpets. Additionally, steam cleaners are versatile, suitable for cleaning various surfaces like tiles, hardwood floors, and upholstery. Environmentally friendly, steam cleaning solely uses water and heat, eliminating the need for chemical cleaning solutions.

On the downside, steam cleaners necessitate regular descaling and maintenance to prevent mineral buildup, adding to the maintenance routine. Moreover, they generally come with a higher initial cost compared to carpet cleaners. While effective for routine cleaning, steam cleaning may not be as potent as carpet cleaners when tackling deep-seated dirt and stubborn stains within carpet fibers. Consider these pros and cons when deciding on the ideal cleaning equipment for your carpets and upholstery.

Pros and Cons of Carpet Cleaning

When considering carpet cleaning options, some may find that steam cleaners offer advantages over carpet cleaners in terms of effectiveness and versatility.

Pros of Carpet Cleaning:

  • Steam cleaners are more effective in killing bacteria and allergens compared to carpet cleaners.
  • Steam cleaners are versatile and can be used on various surfaces such as tiles, hardwood floors, and upholstery.
  • Steam cleaning is a chemical-free and environmentally friendly cleaning method.

Carpet cleaning with a steam cleaner can provide a deep clean that effectively removes dirt and stains while being gentle on the environment. The versatility of steam cleaners allows for the cleaning of multiple surfaces beyond just carpets. Additionally, the elimination of chemical cleaning solutions makes steam cleaning a safer option for both your home and the planet.

One disadvantage of carpet cleaners would be that the intense heat and moisture from steam cleaning may not be suitable for all carpet types and could potentially damage delicate fibers.

Suitability for Different Carpet Types

bhg.com

Steam cleaners are particularly suitable for deep cleaning and sanitizing carpets with natural fibers such as wool or cotton. The high-temperature steam can effectively penetrate deep into the fibers, removing tough stains and odors without the need for harsh chemicals.

On the other hand, carpet cleaners, which use a combination of hot water and cleaning solution, are more appropriate for synthetic carpets, effectively tackling stubborn stains and deep-seated dirt.

If you’re using a carpet cleaner on delicate carpets like wool or cotton, be cautious as the excessive moisture and heat from steam cleaning may damage these fibers. Conversely, steam cleaners are gentle on delicate carpets and can be used for regular maintenance of high-pile or shag carpets.

Carpet cleaners with adjustable settings are versatile and suitable for various carpet types, including low-pile, looped, or textured carpets. However, for specialized carpets such as Berber or sisal, always refer to the manufacturer’s recommendations before deciding between a steam cleaner and a carpet cleaner.

Maintenance Considerations

For optimal performance and longevity of your cleaning equipment, regular maintenance considerations are essential. When it comes to your steam cleaner or carpet cleaner, taking care of these cleaning tools will ensure they stay efficient and effective for a long time.

Here are some important maintenance tips to keep in mind:

  • Descaling and Cleaning: Regularly descale your steam cleaner to prevent mineral buildup, and clean the brushes and filters of your carpet cleaner to maintain their efficiency.
  • Replacement Parts: Consider potential maintenance costs for parts like brushes or belts, especially for carpet cleaners, which may need replacements over time.
  • Environmental Impact: Steam cleaners are a greener option as they use only water and heat, while carpet cleaners may require chemical solutions, so think about sustainability when choosing your maintenance routines.

Cost Analysis

To ensure that your cleaning tools remain cost-effective in the long run, it’s crucial to conduct a thorough cost analysis of both steam cleaners and carpet cleaners. When comparing the cost analysis of a steam cleaner versus a carpet cleaner, consider factors such as initial purchase price, maintenance expenses, and operating costs.

While steam cleaners may have a higher upfront cost, they often require fewer cleaning agents and solutions, reducing long-term expenses. In contrast, carpet cleaners may be more affordable initially but could incur higher costs due to the need for additional cleaning solutions. Additionally, steam cleaners offer a range of cleaning options without the added expense of chemicals, making them a cost-effective choice for regular deep cleaning.

Remember that while hiring a professional for heavy-duty cleaning tasks is an option, owning a steam cleaner can provide you with the flexibility to tackle various cleaning needs efficiently. Consider the key differences in cost between these tools, including time to dry after cleaning, to make the best cost-effective decision for your cleaning requirements.

Environmental Impact

istockphoto.com

Opt for a more environmentally friendly cleaning method by choosing a steam cleaner over a carpet cleaner for minimal impact on the environment. When considering the environmental impact, here are some crucial points to keep in mind:

  • Steam cleaning uses hot water to clean, effectively removing dirt and stains without the need for chemical cleaning solutions.
  • Steam cleaners don’t produce wastewater or residue during the cleaning process, reducing environmental impact compared to carpet cleaners.
  • The use of steam cleaners offers a chemical-free and residue-free cleaning method, making it a greener option for households with allergies or sensitivities.

Tips for Choosing the Right Cleaner

When choosing the right cleaner, keep in mind the specific cleaning needs and environmental considerations to make an informed decision between a steam cleaner and a carpet cleaner.

  • If you’re deciding between steam and carpet to clean, consider that a steam cleaner might be more effective for killing bacteria and allergens, while a carpet cleaner is best for deep cleaning to remove dirt and stains.
  • If you need to clean various surfaces beyond just carpets, a steam cleaner offers greater versatility, whereas a carpet cleaner is specifically designed for carpets.
  • Maintenance-wise, steam cleaners typically require regular descaling, while carpet cleaners may need periodic cleaning of brushes and filters.
  • If you prefer using environmentally friendly methods, note that steam cleaners use only water and heat, while carpet cleaners may involve the use of chemical cleaning solutions like carpet shampoo.
  • If you value quicker drying times, a steam cleaner usually requires less drying time compared to carpet cleaners, making it suitable for households with high foot traffic.

Final Verdict

For a comprehensive cleaning solution that prioritizes efficiency and versatility, consider opting for a steam cleaner over a carpet cleaner. When making your decision, keep in mind the following key points:

  • Effectiveness: Steam cleaners excel in killing bacteria and allergens, providing a thorough deep clean that surpasses what carpet cleaners can achieve.
  • Versatility: Steam cleaners can be used on various surfaces beyond carpets, such as tiles, hardwood floors, and upholstery, offering a multifunctional cleaning solution for your home.
  • Longevity and Eco-friendliness: Steam cleaners have a longer lifespan, require less maintenance, and are more environmentally friendly as they use only water and heat, making them a durable and sustainable investment in the long run.

Steam Cleaner Vs Carpet Cleaner

What is the difference between using a steam cleaner and a carpet cleaner?

When it comes to cleaning carpets, the main difference lies in the method used. A steam cleaner typically uses high pressure and steam to clean the carpets, while a carpet cleaner uses a cleaning solution to shampoo the carpets.

How do steam cleaning and carpet cleaning differ in terms of effectiveness?

Steam cleaning is often preferred for deep stains and heavy-duty cleaning, as it can bring dirt and grime to the surface effectively. On the other hand, carpet cleaning using a shampoo solution is suitable for regular maintenance and freshening up the carpets.

How do you determine whether to steam clean or shampoo your carpet?

The decision to steam clean or shampoo your carpet depends on various factors like the type of stains or level of dirtiness. If you want a deep clean and sanitization, using a steam cleaner may be more appropriate.

When should I consider hiring a professional carpet cleaner instead of using a steam cleaner?

If you have stubborn stains or deep-seated dirt that require specialized treatment, it’s advisable to hire a professional carpet cleaner. They can use advanced equipment and cleaning solutions to achieve optimal results.

Photo of author

AUTHOR

Ira Njoroge

Hey, I’m Ira Njoroge, the founder of MySpaceAffair. Early on in my life, I had a passion to embark on a mission to create a cleaner, and more organized household. With a bachelor's degree in engineering after graduating from the University of Maryland in 2015 and seven years as a General Contractor and professional cleaner, on top of my DIY Enthusiasm. I saw the need for a reliable information source for homeowners. My passion, diligence, experience, and hired professionals confirms the reliability of all the advice given in My Space Affair and I hope to provide you all with reliable and thorough content!