Bissell Carpet Cleaner Vs Rug Doctor: The Best Option in 2024

Published on:
This post may contain affiliate links, and we will be compensated if you buy after clicking on our links
Read our review guidelines.

Are you tired of battling with your carpets, desperately trying to remove every last trace of dirt and stains? Well, get ready for the ultimate showdown between the Bissell Carpet Cleaner vs Rug Doctor. These heavy-duty cleaning machines claim to be the best in the business, but which one truly reigns supreme?

In this article, we will delve into the nitty-gritty details of these carpet cleaners and reveal the key factors that set them apart. So, if you’re curious to discover which machine will give you the sparkling clean carpets of your dreams, keep reading, because the answer might surprise you.

Performance Comparison

The Bissell Big Green carpet cleaner outperforms the Rug Doctor in various tests, providing superior cleaning results. When it comes to carpet cleaning, the Bissell carpet cleaner proves to be more effective than its competitor. With its large brush roll, the Bissell can tackle tough stains and dirt with ease.

On the other hand, the Rug Doctor utilizes a vibrating brush bar, which may not provide the same level of deep cleaning power. In terms of efficiency, both machines require the same number of passes for effective cleaning. However, the Bissell has an advantage with its reclining handle, making it easier to push and pull during the cleaning process.

The Bissell also has the ability to clean in both forward and backward motions, while the Rug Doctor only cleans when pulled towards the user. In conclusion, based on the performance comparison, the Bissell Big Green carpet cleaner is the preferred choice over the Rug Doctor.

Our Top Picks

Best Overall Bissell Carpet Cleaner

Bissell Big Green Professional Carpet Cleaner

Bissell Big Green

Powerful 12 amp motor for deep cleaning.

XL Dirt Lifter Power-Brush with eight rows of bristles for effective dirt removal.

Comes with a long reach hose and tough stain tool for cleaning hard-to-reach areas.

Best Overall Rug Doctor Carpet Cleaner

Rug Doctor Mighty Pro X3 Commercial Carpet Cleaner – Large Red Pet Pack, Includes 48 oz. Pet Carpet Cleaner Solution, Commercial Carpet Cleaning Machine, Powerful One Pass Cleaning System

Rug Doctor Mighty Pro X3

Powerful jets inject cleaning solution deep into carpet fibers for thorough cleaning.

Triple action vibrating brush scrubs all sides of each carpet fiber, ensuring effective dirt and stain removal.

Enhanced vacuum motor with pro-grade suction power aids in faster drying time.

Bissell Big Green

Reasons to Buy

Reason #1 – Powerful 12 amp motor for deep cleaning.

Reason #2 – XL Dirt Lifter Power-Brush with eight rows of bristles for effective dirt removal.

Reason #3 – Comes with a long reach hose and tough stain tool for cleaning hard-to-reach areas.

Reasons to Avoid

Reason #1 – Handle needs to be reclined for brush roll to spin.

If you’re looking for a carpet cleaner that out cleans the leading rental and saves you money in the long run, the Bissell Big Green is the best choice for you. With its powerful 12 amp motor, the Big Green is designed to deliver professional-grade cleaning results. Its XL Dirt Lifter Power-Brush features eight rows of bristles that penetrate deep into carpet fibers, effectively loosening and lifting embedded dirt.

The cleaner also comes with a 9-foot long reach hose and a 6-inch tough stain tool, making it easy to clean stairs, upholstery, and hard-to-reach areas. The Bissell Big Green is compatible with Bissell PRO MAX Clean with Protect Formula, which is specifically formulated to remove tough, ground-in dirt and stains. Additionally, the cleaner boasts two large tanks that keep clean and dirty water separate during cleaning, an adjustable handle for personalized comfort, and a 25-foot power cord for extra reach and maneuverability.

When it comes to cleaning performance, the Bissell Big Green outperforms the Rug Doctor Mighty Pro X3 according to ASTM F2828 testing. So why settle for anything less when you can have the best with the Bissell Big Green?

Best For: Those looking for professional-grade cleaning results and a machine that outperforms rental carpet cleaners.

BrandBissell
ColorGreen
Item Weight51.44 Pounds
Product Dimensions20.5″D x 11″W x 42.25″H
StyleBig Green
Model NameBig Green
Capacity1.75 Gallons
Power SourceCorded Electric
Item Weight51.4 pounds

Rug Doctor Mighty Pro X3

Reasons to Buy

Reason #1 – Powerful jets inject cleaning solution deep into carpet fibers for thorough cleaning.

Reason #2 – Triple action vibrating brush scrubs all sides of each carpet fiber, ensuring effective dirt and stain removal.

Reason #3 – Enhanced vacuum motor with pro-grade suction power aids in faster drying time.

Reasons to Avoid

Reason #1 – The machine only cleans when pulled towards the user, limiting maneuverability.

The Rug Doctor Mighty Pro X3 is the best choice for those seeking a commercial-grade carpet cleaner that delivers professional results with powerful jets and a triple action vibrating brush. This one-pass cleaning system sprays, scrubs, and extracts embedded pet messes, dirt, grime, filth, and odors with professional, commercial-grade results.

Its powerful jets inject cleaning solution deep into carpet fibers, breaking down embedded dirt, grime, stains, and odors. The triple action vibrating brush scrubs all sides of each carpet fiber, releasing embedded dirt, stains, and odors that other commercial and deep cleaning machines may miss.

With its enhanced vacuum motor and pro-grade suction power, this carpet cleaner removes embedded dirt, stains, and odors while aiding in faster drying time. The Rug Doctor Mighty Pro X3 has been awarded the gold rating by the Carpet & Rug Institute for its exceptional soil removal, water removal, and gentleness on carpet.

Best For: Those seeking a commercial-grade carpet cleaner with powerful jets and a triple action vibrating brush for professional results.

BrandRug Doctor
ColorRed
Item Weight47 Pounds
Product Dimensions21″D x 12.5″W x 27.5″H
StyleCommercial Pet Pack Out
Model NameMighty Pro X3
Item Weight47 pounds

Cleaning Mechanism

With its superior performance in cleaning, it’s important to understand the cleaning mechanism of the Bissell Big Green carpet cleaner compared to the Rug Doctor. Both the Bissell and the Rug Doctor are powerful cleaners, but they’ve different approaches to achieving a deep clean.

Here are the key points to note about the cleaning mechanism of the Bissell Big Green carpet cleaner:

  • The Bissell Big Green uses a large brush roll that agitates the carpet fibers, ensuring a thorough clean. This brush roll is designed to reach deep into the carpet, removing embedded dirt and stains.
  • The Bissell Big Green also has strong suction power, which helps to extract dirt and moisture from the carpet. This ensures that your carpets dry faster and reduces the risk of mold or mildew growth.
  • The Bissell Big Green has a large dirty water tank, which means you can clean larger areas without needing to constantly empty and refill the tank.

When it comes to the Rug Doctor:

  • The Rug Doctor uses a vibrating brush bar to agitate the carpet fibers. While this mechanism is effective, it may not provide the same deep clean as the Bissell’s brush roll.
  • The Rug Doctor also has strong suction power and a large dirty water tank, similar to the Bissell Big Green.
  • Both the Bissell Big Green and the Rug Doctor can be used on upholstery, rugs, and carpets, making them versatile deep cleaners.

Number of Passes Required

To achieve optimal cleaning results, both the Bissell Big Green and the Rug Doctor require the same number of passes.

Whether you have a Bissell carpet cleaner or a Rug Doctor, you can expect to make multiple passes over the dirty area to ensure a thorough clean. The reason for this is that ground-in dirt and tough stains require some extra effort to extract. By scrubbing the carpet with multiple passes, you can effectively loosen and remove the dirt and stains from the fibers.

As you make each pass, the machines work to extract the dirty water and store it in their respective water tanks. This ensures that the carpet is left clean and free of any remaining dirt or residue.

Handle Recline Requirement

istockphoto.com

Reclining the handle of the Bissell Big Green carpet cleaner is necessary for the brush roll to spin and ensure efficient cleaning. This handle recline requirement is a notable feature that sets the Bissell apart from the Rug Doctor.

Here are some key points to consider regarding this handle recline requirement:

  • Enhanced Cleaning Power: When the handle is reclined, the brush roll is activated, allowing the Bissell to deeply clean even the dirtiest carpets. This feature ensures that larger amounts of dirt and debris are effectively removed, leaving your carpets looking fresh and revitalized.
  • User-Friendly Maneuverability: The handle recline feature of the Bissell makes it easier to navigate and clean in both forward and backward motions. This means you can cover more ground with each pass, saving you time and effort.
  • Fully Dry and Dried-On Stain Removal: By reclining the handle, the Bissell ensures that your carpets are fully dry after cleaning. This is especially important for removing dried-on stains, as the brush roll can effectively agitate the fibers and loosen stubborn dirt for a wiser cleaning experience.

In comparison, the Rug Doctor lacks a handle recline requirement, making it less user-friendly in terms of maneuverability and potentially compromising its cleaning power. Therefore, if you want a carpet cleaner that offers efficient cleaning, ease of use, and the ability to tackle even the toughest dirt and stains, the Bissell Big Green with its handle recline requirement is the wiser choice.

Forward and Backward Cleaning

The Bissell Big Green carpet cleaner offers the convenience of cleaning in both forward and backward motions, allowing for more efficient and thorough carpet cleaning. This feature sets it apart from the Rug Doctor, which only cleans when pulled towards the user. With the Bissell, you can easily maneuver the machine in any direction, ensuring that no area of your carpets and rugs is missed during the cleaning process.

The ability to clean in both forward and backward motions is particularly beneficial for deep-cleaning tasks. This feature helps to loosen and remove embedded dirt, grime, and stains, resulting in cleaner and fresher carpets. Many customer reviews praise the Bissell for its ease of use and its ability to tackle even the toughest stains.

In professional carpet-cleaning settings, the option to clean in both directions is highly valued. It allows for a more thorough and comprehensive cleaning process, ensuring that every inch of your carpets is effectively cleaned. Whether you’re dealing with high-traffic areas or heavily soiled spots, the Bissell’s forward and backward cleaning feature provides the power and flexibility needed for a deep clean.

Size and Portability

yours.co.uk

When considering the size and portability of the Bissell Big Green and Rug Doctor carpet cleaners, you’ll find that both machines fold up easily and fit into different car models for convenient transportation. This means you can easily take them with you to clean carpets in different locations without any hassle.

Here are some key points to consider about the size and portability of these machines:

  • Both the Bissell Big Green and Rug Doctor are designed to be compact, allowing for easy storage when not in use. This is especially important if you have limited space in your home or storage area.
  • The compact size of these machines also makes them easy to move around, so you can clean carpets in different rooms without any difficulty.
  • Whether you have a small car or a larger vehicle, both the Bissell and Rug Doctor can fit into different car models. This makes transportation a breeze, allowing you to bring the machine wherever it’s needed.

Preparing for Use

To get started with the Bissell Big Green or Rug Doctor carpet cleaners, preparing for use is a simple process. Both machines can be easily prepared with the necessary water and cleaning solution to ensure the best carpet cleaning results.

For the Bissell rental, it’s easy to fill and prepare. It consists of four parts that fit together easily, allowing you to quickly assemble the cleaner. You can fill the Bissell rental using a laundry tub, kitchen sink, or even a bathtub, making it convenient and versatile.

On the other hand, the Rug Doctor requires a bit more preparation. Before using the cleaner, you need to mix a gallon of hot water and cleaning solution in a separate bucket. Once the mixture is ready, you can pour it into the machine and start cleaning.

Regardless of the carpet cleaner you choose, it’s important to ensure that you have enough water and cleaning solution for the cleaning process. This will ensure that your carpets are thoroughly cleaned and refreshed.

Bissell Big Green

Get ready to experience the deep cleaning power and convenience of the Bissell Big Green carpet cleaner. When it comes to tackling stubborn stains, the Bissell Big Green is a top pick in our tests. Here are three reasons why:

  • The Bissell Big Green is specifically designed to handle tough stains like wine stains on carpets. Its powerful suction and rotating brush roll work together to lift and remove deep-seated dirt and stains, leaving your carpet looking fresh and clean.
  • With its large water tank capacity, the Bissell Big Green allows you to clean more area without the need for frequent refills. This means less interruption during your cleaning process and more time saved.
  • Users have praised the Bissell Big Green for its user-friendly design. Its easy-to-use controls and maneuverability make it a breeze to operate, even for those who are new to carpet cleaning. Plus, the Bissell Big Green’s ergonomic handle and lightweight construction ensure a comfortable cleaning experience.

When it comes to carpet cleaning, the Bissell Big Green is a reliable and effective choice. Its deep cleaning capabilities, large water tank, and user-friendly design make it a top contender in the Bissell vs Rug Doctor debate.

Rug Doctor

The contrast to the Bissell Big Green’s deep cleaning capabilities and user-friendly design is the Rug Doctor, a red carpet cleaning machine known for its mixed reviews and criticism regarding its weight and maneuverability. Some users have found the Rug Doctor to be heavy and difficult to maneuver, which can make the cleaning process more challenging.

Additionally, the Rug Doctor has received mixed reviews, with some users finding it effective in removing dirt and stains, while others have been disappointed with the results. One common complaint is that the Rug Doctor leaves carpets wetter compared to the Bissell Big Green. This can be problematic as it may take longer for the carpet to dry completely, increasing the risk of mold and mildew growth.

Despite these criticisms, the Rug Doctor does have some notable features. It has a powerful cleaning head that can effectively remove dirt, pet hair, and even tough stains like red wine. It also has a nozzle that can easily reach into tight spaces. However, if weight and maneuverability are a concern for you, the Rug Doctor may not be the best option.

Final Verdict

istockphoto.com

Considering the drawbacks of Rug Doctor machines, it’s clear that the final verdict favors the BISSELL Big Green carpet cleaner. Here are three key reasons why:

1. Superior Cleaning Performance: In performance tests, the Bissell Big Green consistently outperforms the Rug Doctor in terms of cleaning effectiveness. With its large brush roll and ability to clean in both forward and backward motions, the Bissell ensures a thorough and efficient cleaning process. Rug Doctor, on the other hand, relies on a vibrating brush bar and can only clean when pulled towards the user.

2. Ease of Use: Users have reported that the BISSELL Big Green is more user-friendly compared to Rug Doctor machines. The Bissell’s handle needs to be reclined for the brush roll to spin, making it easier to control and maneuver. In contrast, Rug Doctor machines have been criticized for their heavy weight and difficulty in maneuvering, making them less convenient to use.

3. Larger Water Tank Capacity: Another advantage of the BISSELL Big Green is its larger water tank capacity compared to Rug Doctor. This means that you can clean a larger area without having to refill the tank as frequently, saving you time and effort.

Bissell Carpet Cleaner Vs Rug Doctor FAQs

Which is the best carpet cleaner: Bissell or Rug Doctor?

The choice between Bissell and Rug Doctor depends on your specific needs and preferences. Bissell Pro Heat 2X and Rug Doctor are both reputable brands with their own set of features that cater to different cleaning requirements. Consider factors such as cleaning performance, ease of use, and additional features to determine the best option for your needs.

What are the differences between Bissell Pro Heat 2X and Rug Doctor?

The main differences lie in the technologies and functionalities offered by Bissell Pro Heat 2X and Rug Doctor. While Bissell Pro Heat 2X emphasizes features like Pro Heat 2X Revolution Pet Pro, Rug Doctor offers unique functionalities such as dry the carpet and revolution hydro steam. Comparing the specific features and cleaning modes of each product can help in understanding their differences.

Can Bissell or Rug Doctor also be used as a vacuum?

Bissell Pro Heat 2X and Rug Doctor are primarily carpet cleaners and are not designed to function as traditional vacuums. While they are not intended for general vacuuming, these machines are tailored to deep clean and shampoo carpets effectively.

Do Bissell and Rug Doctor affiliate links earn a commission?

Yes, both Bissell and Rug Doctor offer affiliate programs where individuals or businesses can promote their products. When customers make a purchase through these affiliate links, the affiliate may earn a commission on the sale.

Which carpet cleaner uses less water: Bissell or Rug Doctor?

Bissell and Rug Doctor have their own mechanisms for controlling water usage during cleaning. While Bissell may have features like clean water and express clean mode, Rug Doctor may have different capabilities such as drier cleaning mode. Comparative analysis of each machine’s water usage can help in making a well-informed decision.

Can Bissell or Rug Doctor effectively clean heavily soiled or dirty carpets?

Both Bissell and Rug Doctor are designed to tackle heavily soiled or dirty carpets. With their powerful cleaning modes like max clean and specific cleaning techniques, these machines can effectively deep clean and refresh heavily stained carpets.

What are the advantages of using a Bissell or Rug Doctor carpet cleaner over steam mops?

Compared to steam mops, Bissell and Rug Doctor  are specifically designed for carpets and provide a more comprehensive solution for eliminating tough stains and dirt from carpeted surfaces.

Can the hose of Bissell or Rug Doctor machines be used for upholstery cleaning?

Both Bissell and Rug Doctor offer additional accessories and functionalities that enable cleaning of upholstery and other surfaces in addition to carpets. The hose attachments for these machines can be used for effectively cleaning upholstery and other similar surfaces.

Photo of author

AUTHOR

Ira Njoroge

Hey, I’m Ira Njoroge, the founder of MySpaceAffair. Early on in my life, I had a passion to embark on a mission to create a cleaner, and more organized household. With a bachelor's degree in engineering after graduating from the University of Maryland in 2015 and seven years as a General Contractor and professional cleaner, on top of my DIY Enthusiasm. I saw the need for a reliable information source for homeowners. My passion, diligence, experience, and hired professionals confirms the reliability of all the advice given in My Space Affair and I hope to provide you all with reliable and thorough content!